Categories: FoodNYC

Apparently I Only Ate Round Things Last Night

You guys.

My mom is the pickiest eater I’ve ever met, and I found another restaurant that she liked. This is a post-Christmas miracle. She came in for dinner last night, and I’d wanted to try Casa Nonna since it’s in my ‘hood and Ali really liked it. The first time I asked her to check out the menu, she declared too many ingredients she didn’t know, so I have no idea how I actually talked her into it.

It’s part of the BLT group of restaurants (but without BLT in its name, tricky), and it has a cute, cozy your-Italian-grandma’s house feel. The tufted leather banquettes actually remind me a lot of the tufted leather bar thingy my grandma used to have in her basement, so I declare it accurate in the your-Italian-grandma department. See also: wood paneling.

Thing #1 that reminded me of Quartino in Chicago: the wine was served in quartinos (which means quarter liter in Italian. I looked it up at the table, since I was curious. Thank god for iPhones.)

Thing #2 that reminded me of Quartino in Chicago: I ordered a quartino of soave for me and my mom. (Just kidding, Dad, mom did not actually have any.) I remembered ordering it at Quartino and it being a crowd-pleaser.

(The awkward ponytail and pose are brought to you by my dirty hair and hating how I look head-on when my hair is up.)

See? No.

As a runner and daughter of an Italian lady, I consider myself a connoisseur of carbs, and I recommend going to Casa Nonna just for this, the focaccia with some sort of very delicious cheese and seasonings.

Since I’m working my way through a big thing of pasta I made earlier in the week and planned on eating a bagel this morning, I decided to skip the pasta last night and go for two appetizers. My mom ended up sharing some of her pasta with me, too, which was wonderful. AND SHE LIKED IT!!! Double wonderful. For appetizer numero uno, I went with the braised meatballs with tomato sauce. There was also some cheese, and it, too, was wonderful. The meatballs had a bit of a kick, and they were very good, though, of course, not as good as my mom’s. But almost.

For numero due, I had the fried risotto balls. (So, yes, I only had balls for dinner.) These actually weren’t very flavorful, but anything that involves risotto and breading can never be that bad in my book.

To finish off the ball theme, we had some sorbet for dessert. My mom loved every single thing that was placed in front of us last night, which made me incredibly happy.

We didn’t try it, but they do a $35 four-course prix fixe dinner which rotates (monthly? every so often?) and features food from different parts of Italy. I think last night was Calabria.

What are your favorite spherically-shaped foods?

Theodora Blanchfield

View Comments

  • There is nothing wrong with balls! Thanks to the meatball shop, balls are back! I like your hair up!

  • Yes and Yes, I did like the food very much.
    I'll let you in on a litle secret my daughter knows that
    desserts are my favorite, not only did she choose this restaurant knowing I might like the food but also pretended
    she wanted a dessert she picked one that I would enjoy

    Thank you, lovely evening with my daughter makes a mother
    proud!!

  • you look really pretty with your hair pulled back like that! Billy and I will be in NYC for his birthday weekend Feb 2-6. must see you! run, wine, both, whatever. xo

  • Aaaaah I'm so glad you went to Casa Nonna! And SO glad you and your mom both loved it. So so so good. I got the meatballs and risotto balls too, and loved them both. And yes, wow, that bread. I still think about it.

    Lucky girl — you live so close to the restaurant! Hope you had a great weekend and glad you enjoyed the meal!

Share
Published by
Theodora Blanchfield
Tags: restaurant

Recent Posts

And So I Face the Final Curtain…

No idea why I chose Frank Sinatra lyrics to name my last post on this…

2 years ago

Like a Butterfly

As I mentioned in my last post, I've really been going through it with headaches.…

3 years ago

The One About the Jacket

(tw for diet culture talk—mostly how it's BS, but how it's affected me, too) This…

3 years ago

Complicit in Diet Culture

I have been thinking about this post for a while—on why diet culture is unhealthy…

4 years ago

Beating Yourself Up About Self-Care Is…Not Self-Care

I woke up this morning already feeling anxious. (Yay!) My standard iPhone alarm is set…

4 years ago

The Midnight Library Review

I read The Midnight Library over the weekend, and I need to talk about it.…

4 years ago